Hello, Thanks for signing up for MarketBeat Daily Ratings—we’re excited to have you on board. Every weekday, you’ll get a curated summary of new “Buy” and “Sell” ratings from Wall Street’s top-rated analysts, the latest stock news, and bonus investing content—all delivered straight to your inbox. You’re just two quick steps away from completing your sign-up: 1. Make sure our emails go to your inboxGmail users:
Mobile: Tap the three dots (…) in the top right and select Move to Inbox or Move to Primary
Desktop: Click the folder icon at the top and select Move to Inbox or Primary Apple Mail users:
Tap our email address at the top (next to From: on mobile), then select Add to VIP Other providers:
Reply to this message and add newsletters@analystratings.net to your contacts 2. Confirm your subscriptionClick this link to confirm your subscription. This verifies your account and ensures you receive your newsletters without interruption instead of getting stuck in your spam filter. Confirm your subscription here. After you confirm, feel free to download our popular free report, "7 Stocks to Buy and Hold Forever" with this link. Thanks again for subscribing—we look forward to being part of your investing journey. 
Matthew Paulson
Founder and CEO, MarketBeat. P.S. If you didn’t mean to subscribe, no problem—you can unsubscribe here.
Further Reading from MarketBeat
Carmax at 5-Year Lows: Is Now The Time to Buy?By Thomas Hughes. Posted: 4/16/2026. 
Key Points
- Carmax stock is poised to plunge following weak guidance.
- Contracting margins and weak demand are undercutting cash flow and capital return.
- A convergence of factors, including suspended buybacks, suggests new long-term lows are coming.
- Special Report: Elon Musk already made me a “wealthy man”
Carmax (NYSE: KMX) shares are trading near five-year lows, creating an intriguing opportunity. However, while the company appears insulated from financial collapse, market forces are aligned to keep this stock from moving higher in the near term. The takeaway from the fiscal Q4 2026 results and forward guidance is that business conditions are suboptimal — so much so that management paused its share buybacks to preserve capital. That is a significant detail: FY2025 buyback activity had previously reduced the share count by a high-single-digit amount.
For a moment…
Forget about Trump’s ties to Israel.
Forget about reports of Iran’s nuclear program.
Because my research has led me to believe we’re risking World War 3 with Iran for a completely different reason. Click here to find out what it is.
The likely outcome is that Carmax weathers these changes and eventually comes out ahead. The questions are how long that will take and how much lower the stock may fall before it happens. Carmax Near Price Floor: Sell-Side Support Isn’t FirmTechnically, the stock is trading near a potential price floor in early Q2 2026, roughly aligned with COVID-19-era lows. The problem is that the 2020 price action led to a quick rebound, while 2026’s action has languished at low levels with little to entice buyers. Analysts who might otherwise establish a floor are reluctant to do so given the guidance update and the sentiment trend. 
MarketBeat’s data shows a high-conviction Reduce rating based on 18 analysts, and sentiment has been deteriorating. The 2026 trend includes numerous downgrades and price-target cuts, with consensus assuming fair value near the technical floor and the low end around $28. In that scenario, KMX could easily drop to fresh lows and then fall more than 25% before finding a bottom. Short sellers are adding to positions in this market. Short interest isn’t astronomical — roughly 10% — but it has been rising and is large enough to create a headwind for the stock. Short interest could increase further given the buyback pause and the potential for weaker upcoming reports. The deciding factor will be the institutions. They own about 99% of the company’s shares, and their activity is ambiguous. The data shows institutional accumulation in early 2026 ahead of the Q1 release, but the trailing 12-month balance is essentially even — buying and selling are balanced. That reflects a market in limbo, highly sensitive to news. The risk is that the guidance and the buyback pause push institutions toward distribution, driving the stock through critical support to fresh lows. In that case, short sellers are likely to lean into their trades, adding momentum and depth to any decline. Carmax Headwinds Build, Impair Outlook for 2026Carmax struggled in its fiscal Q4, with margins contracting amid weak demand and pricing pressure. Total unit sales rose just 0.7%, driven by a 3% increase in wholesale that was offset by a 0.8% decline in retail. Comparable retail units fell nearly 2%, and total retail sales slipped more than 1%. The guidance that followed left investors unimpressed. Margin details were also disappointing. Adjusted EPS of $0.34 exceeded MarketBeat’s consensus but was down more than 40% year over year even after the benefit of buybacks. Management expects margin contraction to continue. Rising Debt and Margin Pressures Sap Enthusiasm for KMX StockOther concerns include the balance sheet and rising leverage. The company is not near bankruptcy, but 2025’s activity left it with less cash, higher inventory, and reduced equity, pushing leverage above target and creating expected weakness for the year ahead. Guidance includes targeted cost savings from turnaround efforts, but those are likely to be offset by lower margins and profitability. Competitive pressure is another risk. Carmax is behind on digital offerings and struggling to gain share against more digitally focused operators such as Carvana (NYSE: CVNA). Carvana sells a larger share of its vehicles digitally and generally captures higher margins. Carmax offers similar features but only a low-double-digit percentage of its sales are completed entirely online. Possible catalysts this year include operational improvements tied to the new CEO, Keith Barr, who took over earlier this year and is expected to accelerate digitization and efficiency efforts. Market share gains could follow as smaller used-car dealers consolidate. The question is whether Carmax can capitalize on that opportunity ahead of competitors and do so profitably. Interest-rate trends could also help if cuts come sooner than expected; currently, futures markets do not price in the next cut until sometime in 2027. |
